Chapter 4 - WHY PRESTON CALLED 911
The question followed Madeline into Natalie’s guest room.
If Preston had knowingly wanted her unconscious, why call an ambulance?
Poppy’s statement suggested he gave Serena the bottle.
Serena suggested he knew what it was for.
But Preston had made the emergency call himself.
Phone records confirmed it.
He had called quickly.
He had followed the dispatcher’s instructions.
He had stayed with Madeline until paramedics arrived.
Nothing about that behavior resembled a man calmly waiting for a plan to succeed.
Madeline’s attorney, Erin Walsh, warned her against filling uncertainty with the worst possible answer.
“You need evidence, not a story that feels emotionally satisfying.”
Madeline hated that Erin was right.
Two days later Preston requested a meeting through attorneys.
Madeline agreed.
Not alone.
Preston looked terrible.
“I knew Serena wanted you to sleep.”
Madeline’s entire body went still.
He continued quickly.
“I didn’t think she meant drugging you.”
“What exactly did you think she meant?”
Preston looked ashamed.
For months Madeline had barely slept.
Her mother had undergone cancer treatment.
Poppy had started having nightmares.
Madeline was also preparing to return to work after almost five years of primarily staying home.
She was exhausted.
Preston and Serena had talked repeatedly about it.
Without Madeline.
Serena kept saying Madeline needed “one night where she couldn’t keep getting back up.”
Preston admitted he had joked that prescription sleep medication was the only thing strong enough to stop him from checking emails.
Then Serena asked if he still had the bottle.
He gave it to her.
“Why?”
“I thought she wanted it for herself.”
Madeline stared.
“You expect me to believe that?”
“No.”
His answer surprised her.
“I expect you not to believe anything I say yet.”
He looked at his hands.
“Sunday night, I walked into the living room and saw you on the floor.”
He panicked.
He called 911.
Then Serena said something.
“What?”
Preston’s voice dropped.
“She told me not to mention the bottle.”
Madeline went cold.
“And you listened.”
“Yes.”
“Why?”
“Because I realized what she might have done.”
“And instead of telling the paramedics?”
“I was scared.”
“For yourself.”
Preston nodded.
“Yes.”
That was his first unforgivable choice.
Maybe he had not intended Madeline’s collapse.
But once it happened, he protected himself before helping doctors understand why.
The ambulance call no longer proved innocence.
May you like
It proved he did not want her dead.
Those were not the same thing.
