Chapter 14 - THE LAST CHANCE TO KEEP LYING
Gabriel appeared at the evidentiary hearing under subpoena.
He looked almost unchanged.
That angered Mateo more than it should have.
Same dark hair.
Same controlled expression.
Same habit of straightening his cuffs before answering.
Only the Vargas Construction shirt was gone.
Gabriel denied killing Daniela.
He admitted lying about being at Rosa’s house.
He claimed he did so because he feared police would misunderstand his argument with Daniela.
The prosecutor asked why he frightened Elena into silence.
“I didn’t.”
Elena’s forensic interview said otherwise.
Gabriel blamed childhood confusion.
Then he was shown the photograph.
He admitted he was the man beside Daniela.
He was shown bank records.
He admitted Daniela had confronted him about money.
He was shown Rosa’s corrected statement.
His face changed.
For the first time, he looked toward Mateo.
Rosa had done the one thing Gabriel apparently believed she never would.
She chose truth over protecting him.
During a recess, Gabriel’s lawyer approached prosecutors.
There were discussions Mateo was not allowed to hear.
Nina refused to speculate.
“Whatever he offers, this hearing is about your conviction.”
Mateo nodded.
The judge later asked the state a direct question.
Given the recanted alibi, newly discovered financial motive, corroborated child disclosure, photographic evidence, and substantial impeachment of a key trial witness, did the prosecution continue to have confidence in Mateo’s conviction?
The assistant state’s attorney stood.
“No, Your Honor.”
Mateo stopped breathing.
That was not release.
Not yet.
The state requested time to determine whether it would retry him.
The judge scheduled another hearing.
Gabriel left through a side door.
Rosa remained seated behind the attorneys.
Mateo looked back once.
She did not wave.
She simply pressed one hand against her mouth.
Outside, reporters waited.
Inside, Mateo returned to custody.
May you like
But for the first time since Daniela died, nobody in that courtroom was asking him to prove he was innocent.
They were asking whether the state could still justify keeping him imprisoned.
