Chapter 3 - THE CALL DENNIS DIDN’T WANT SOPHIE TO ANSWER
Jenna Alvarez did not question Sophie repeatedly.
A trained child interviewer handled the necessary conversation once, with age-appropriate language, while Elmer waited outside.
The adults learned only what they needed for safety.
A woman had called Dennis’s phone the previous week.
Sophie heard the name Leah.
Dennis went into the garage to talk, but Sophie followed.
She heard the woman ask:
“Does she know I’m her mother?”
Dennis discovered Sophie listening.
That night he told her Leah was “a sick lady who tells lies.”
Two days later, Sophie found the birth certificate in a folder inside Dennis’s home office.
She recognized her own name.
She could read only a few words.
One was Leah.
She put the certificate in her backpack.
Dennis discovered it Thursday while driving her toward Elmer’s house.
According to Sophie, he became frightened.
Not angry at first.
Frightened.
He told her Trisha could never see the paper.
Sophie said she would show Trisha after Hawaii.
That was when Dennis took her into the attic.
The locked wardrobe was punishment and concealment at once.
DHS initiated a safety assessment. Police opened a child-endangerment investigation. Elmer’s house was inspected before Sophie could stay there.
The attic itself became a problem.
The old hatch had no barrier. Cleaning chemicals sat in the laundry room. The back door lock was easy for a child to open.
At sixty-eight, Elmer disliked having strangers tell him how to arrange his own home.
Then he remembered the wardrobe.
He installed everything they asked for.
Sophie was released to him under a temporary safety plan while court proceedings began.
The decision carried immediate consequences.
Dennis called from Hawaii using another number.
“You took my daughter.”
“You left her locked in my attic.”
“I knew you’d be home Monday.”
“She didn’t know that.”
“I was teaching her not to steal private documents.”
“She is five.”
Dennis became quiet.
Then:
“You have no idea what Leah is like.”
“Then tell me.”
“I can’t.”
“Can’t or won’t?”
Dennis ended the call.
Trisha flew home alone the next morning.
She did not go to the house she shared with Dennis.
She went to her mother Barbara Carter’s home in Beaverton.
Within two hours, Trisha called Elmer again.
This time her voice was different.
“My mother knows.”
“Knows what?”
Trisha swallowed.
“That Leah had a baby.”
Elmer stood in Sophie’s newly prepared bedroom.
“And she never told you?”
“No.”
“Why?”
May you like
Trisha began crying.
“Because she says the baby was Dennis’s.”
Related Stories
