Chapter 6 - The Person I Expected to Help Asked Me a Harder Question
Dr. Fallon agreed to speak with Vittorio once he made it clear that he had never consented to the appointment materials submitted in his name.
She did not immediately take his side.
That irritated him more than he wanted to admit.
“I saw the video,” Vittorio said after his attorney arranged for it to be provided appropriately.
“I understand.”
“Then you understand Bianca should never be near Lucy again.”
“I understand that what’s shown is serious.”
“That sounds like the same sentence with softer words.”
Dr. Fallon did not react.
“My job is not to tell you what you want to hear because you’re angry. My job is to help make sure Lucy is safe and to understand what she has experienced.”
Vittorio almost ended the call.
Then she asked the question that stopped him.
“When did you first notice your daughter was afraid in her own home?”
He had no answer.
Not because there had been no signs.
Because he had renamed them.
Quiet.
Moody.
Still grieving.
Attached to him.
Going through a phase.
Dr. Fallon explained that she would not use Bianca’s submitted behavior log as established fact. She would note who created it, what it claimed, and what independent information did or did not support it.
That distinction mattered.
Bianca had wanted the authority of a professional record.
She did not automatically get it.
After the call, Vittorio went to Lucy.
She was building a small wooden sailboat on the floor—the kind Marcus used to bring her.
Vittorio sat beside her.
“Do you want me to put that away?”
Lucy shook her head.
“Uncle Marcus was nice when he gave it to me.”
The answer hurt because it was so simple.
Lucy was capable of holding two truths at once.
Marcus had once been kind.
Marcus had later frightened her.
Adults were the ones insisting people had to be only one thing.
That afternoon, another person surprised Vittorio.
Bianca’s mother, Margaret, called.
Vittorio expected defense.
Instead, she said, “Do not let Bianca talk to Lucy right now.”
He went quiet.
Margaret had always adored her daughter.
“Why?”
“Because Bianca will try to explain before she’s ready to admit what she did.”
“You knew?”
“I knew she was overwhelmed. I did not know about the bowl.”
Margaret sounded sick.
Then she said something more important.
“For years, Bianca has believed it’s her job to save Marcus from himself.”
Vittorio leaned back in his chair.
Margaret explained that their father had died when Marcus was seventeen and Bianca was fifteen. Their mother fell apart for a period afterward. Bianca became the responsible one.
She covered missed school.
Paid his bills.
Lied when he wrecked their mother’s car.
Later, when Marcus’s marriage failed, Bianca paid his rent.
“When he loses control of something,” Margaret said, “Bianca doesn’t ask whether he caused it. She asks how to protect him.”
That explained the invoices.
It explained why Bianca covered Marcus.
It did not explain why she had turned on a seven-year-old.
Vittorio said so.
Margaret was silent.
Then she answered, “Maybe Lucy wasn’t the problem.”
“What does that mean?”
“Maybe Lucy was the one person Bianca couldn’t control the story around.”
May you like
For the first time, Vittorio considered that Bianca’s cruelty toward Lucy might not have started because she disliked his daughter.
It might have started because she was afraid of what Lucy could say.
Related Stories
