Chapter 3 - Elsie’s Teacher Had Already Asked the Wrong Question
Vittorio canceled the rest of the party.
He did it quietly.
Family members were told Elsie was overwhelmed and needed rest.
Nobody was given a dramatic explanation in the foyer.
Nobody was invited to form a jury around a frightened three-year-old.
Vittorio called Elsie’s pediatrician.
Then he called Rachel Bennett, director of Elsie’s preschool.
He introduced himself as Elsie’s grandfather.
“I understand you contacted Marcus about bruising.”
There was a pause.
“Yes.”
“When?”
“Thursday afternoon.”
“What exactly did you observe?”
Ms. Bennett became careful.
Appropriately careful.
She explained that one of Elsie’s teachers noticed bruising on her upper arm while helping her wash paint from her hands.
Nobody had immediately concluded abuse.
Toddlers and preschoolers bruised themselves constantly.
But Elsie said something unusual when the teacher asked whether she had bumped into something.
She whispered:
“I wasn’t listening fast enough.”
Vittorio closed his eyes.
Ms. Bennett continued.
The teacher notified the director.
Ms. Bennett contacted Marcus.
Marcus said Elsie was clumsy and had recently started throwing tantrums.
Then Helena called the school herself.
That surprised Vittorio.
“Why would my wife call you?”
“She said she was one of Elsie’s regular caregivers.”
“She is.”
“She told me Elsie had a habit of inventing stories when corrected.”
There it was.
The birthday insult had not come from nowhere.
Helena had already been building a version of Elsie.
Difficult.
Dishonest.
Wild.
Ms. Bennett then said something more troubling.
“When we told Marcus we needed to document the conversation, he sounded nervous.”
Vittorio looked across his study toward Marcus.
His son was sitting on the leather sofa.
Helena had been asked to remain elsewhere in the house.
Elsie was upstairs with the longtime nanny, Grace, who had returned early after Vittorio called her.
“What happened next?” Vittorio asked.
“Mr. Carter said he could provide something in writing.”
The paper.
“Did you ask him to?”
“No.”
That changed everything.
The school had not demanded a written explanation.
Helena had created one.
Vittorio ended the call and faced Marcus.
“She volunteered that statement.”
Marcus nodded.
“Why?”
“Mom thought it would calm things down.”
“Why did anything need calming down?”
Marcus looked toward the closed study doors.
“Dad, you know what Mom’s like.”
“No. Apparently I know what everyone tells me she’s like after the fact.”
Marcus rubbed both hands over his face.
Vittorio remembered Elsie’s exact words.
There were so many times you just stood there and watched her hit me.
Not once.
Not today.
So many times.
“How long?”
Marcus did not answer.
Vittorio leaned closer.
“How long has your mother been hitting Elsie?”
Marcus looked miserable.
“She smacks her hand.”
“That isn’t what Elsie said.”
“She gets rough sometimes.”
“How long?”
“Since this summer.”
Four months.
Vittorio stared at his son.
Four months during which Marcus brought Elsie to Sunday dinners.
Four months during which Helena bought her clothes and corrected her table manners and complained that she was “too sensitive.”
Four months during which Vittorio had admired Helena for helping a single father cope.
Then Marcus said something Vittorio had not expected.
“It got worse after I moved back here.”
Vittorio’s anger shifted.
Marcus and Elsie had moved into the family estate five months earlier after Marcus’s business began struggling.
May you like
Which meant the house itself was part of the problem.
And Vittorio had been living inside it without understanding what was happening upstairs.
Related Stories
