Chapter 3 - What Lily Had Been InvestigatingMaya Ellis lived with her mother in Worcester.
Rachel contacted them officially.
Victor did not.
That was one of the first boundaries I enforced.
My old instinct wanted information immediately.
My new life required patience.
Maya’s attorney called Rachel the following afternoon.
There was a reason the Ellis family had disappeared from St. Alden.
Five months earlier, Maya attended a private gathering at a lakeside club outside Wellesley.
Ethan.
Brandon.
Tyler.
Several other students.
Maya ended the night in an emergency room with a concussion, fractured wrist, and severe dehydration.
The university described it as “an alcohol-related recreational accident.”
Maya’s family never believed that.
She told them she had been subjected to a violent hazing ritual by a student social club Ethan controlled.
Not a recognized fraternity.
Something older.
Smaller.
Much wealthier.
The Hart Society.
Membership passed through families.
Ethan’s father belonged.
So did Brandon’s.
Tyler’s grandfather had chaired it decades earlier.
Maya had been pressured into participating because she wanted a prestigious student-government appointment.
She refused partway through.
Things escalated.
No one called emergency services for nearly an hour.
Then the story became:
Maya drank too much and fell from a dock.
Sound familiar.
The Ellises considered litigation.
Then bills arrived.
Hospital.
Tuition.
Lost work for Maya’s mother.
A private settlement followed.
No admission of wrongdoing.
Maya withdrew.
The settlement itself was legal.
What troubled Rachel was what came before it.
A campus conduct officer wrote an initial report identifying Ethan, Brandon, and Tyler as persons present.
The final report omitted their names.
Why?
The university said insufficient evidence.
Lily apparently did not believe that.
She had met Maya through a mutual friend.
For six weeks, she investigated quietly.
She collected event records.
Student messages.
Names.
One caterer from the lake event.
Two students who left early.
A valet who remembered a car leaving before the ambulance arrived.
The folded paper beside her hospital bed was part of that work.
Maya.
Dock.
Three names.
Lily had carried it to the Back Bay fundraiser because one of her sources agreed to speak in person.
“Who?” I asked Rachel.
“We don’t know.”
Lily did.
She typed the initials:
C.R.
The Chronicle staff list contained a junior named Caleb Ross.
Rachel contacted him.
His phone went directly to voicemail.
His roommate said Caleb left campus unexpectedly that morning.
For Vermont.
Family emergency.
Victor glanced at me.
We both knew what that phrase sometimes meant.
Pressure.
I told him:
“Don’t go after the kid.”
“I wasn’t going to.”
“You were thinking it.”
“So were you.”
He was right.
Then Lily typed something else.
CHECK HER BAG.
Her canvas reporter’s bag had arrived with hospital belongings.
Inside:
Notebook.
Portable charger.
Wallet.
Campus ID.
No phone.
No digital recorder.
No laptop.
Her phone was missing.
Rachel checked the property inventory from the ambulance.
No phone had been collected.
Lily wrote:
ETHAN TOOK IT.
That transformed the case.
If true, the assault was not only violence.
It involved destruction or concealment of potential evidence.
Rachel asked what had been on the phone.
Lily typed:
CALEB AUDIO.
MAYA DOCS.
PHOTO.
“What photo?”
Lily’s fingers stopped.
She stared at the screen.
Then wrote:
THEIR FATHERS.
That made no immediate sense.
Rachel asked.
Lily shook her head weakly.
Too tired.
We stopped.
The nurse dimmed the room.
I sat beside Lily until she slept.
Victor stayed near the window.
“You know what I’m thinking,” he said.
“Yes.”
“You want me to tell you not to.”
“Yes.”
He folded his arms.
“Don’t.”
I looked at him.
“Seventeen years ago, we wouldn’t have waited for police.”
“No.”
“We would’ve put those fathers in rooms until they explained themselves.”
Victor’s face hardened.
“And how many people did we call guilty because we wanted answers before facts?”
Enough.
He continued.
“You called me because you were afraid you’d become that man again.”
I looked at Lily.
“Yes.”
May you like
“Then don’t make me help you.”
That was the first thing Victor Kane ever said to me that sounded like friendship instead of loyalty.
Related Stories
