Chapter 2 - The Woman Who Claimed Claire Had Been a Stranger
I met Natalie Rhodes twenty-two months after Claire died.
Claire had died from complications following emergency abdominal surgery.
No mystery.
No suspicious accident.
No unanswered crime.
A bowel obstruction became sepsis frighteningly fast. She spent six days in intensive care.
Then she was gone.
Sophie had been four.
For the first year, I functioned mechanically.
Work.
School.
Laundry.
Therapy appointments.
Frozen dinners.
Answering impossible questions from a child who believed heaven should have visiting hours.
Dating was not part of my life.
Then Natalie appeared.
We met at a benefit auction in Manhattan.
At least, that was the story I had believed.
I owned a midsized commercial architecture firm.
One of our clients sponsored the event.
Natalie worked in philanthropic strategy for the Vale Family Foundation, created by her father.
She approached me near the silent-auction tables.
“You look like you’d rather be at the dentist.”
I laughed.
That was the beginning.
She was clever.
Fast.
Unsentimental.
Most importantly, she never competed with Claire.
At first.
When I told her I was widowed, she said:
“You don’t have to make your old life smaller to make room for me.”
I remembered that sentence while staring at Claire’s broken box.
It sounded different now.
Six months into our relationship, Natalie met Sophie.
She was patient.
Never demanded affection.
Never called herself Mom.
At the time, I thought she understood boundaries unusually well.
Now I wondered whether she had simply understood Sophie unusually well because she had already studied us.
That possibility made me feel paranoid.
So I resisted it.
I asked Natalie directly.
“Did you know Claire before we met?”
“No.”
“Did you know her name?”
“Maybe through Dad. I don’t remember.”
“You told me you’d never heard of her.”
“I hadn’t.”
“What did your father hire her for?”
“I don’t know that he hired her.”
“Why is she standing beside him?”
“My father met thousands of people.”
I turned the photograph over.
Keep his records.
Natalie’s eyes followed the words.
“Claire wrote weird things when she worked.”
That sentence stopped me.
“When she worked where?”
Natalie blinked.
Then realized what she had done.
I stepped closer.
“You just told me you didn’t know anything about their connection.”
“I mean generally.”
“No.”
I pointed at the photograph.
“You knew Claire worked with your father.”
Natalie’s jaw tightened.
“Years ago.”
“How many years?”
“Before you.”
“How do you know?”
Silence.
Sophie was still in my arms.
That mattered.
Whatever conversation came next would not happen in front of her.
I called my sister Hannah, who was downstairs with wedding guests.
“Take Sophie to your house.”
“What happened?”
“The wedding is off.”
Silence.
Then:
“Is Sophie okay?”
“Yes.”
That was the correct first question.
Hannah arrived five minutes later.
Natalie tried to stop her.
“You cannot just remove Sophie because Ethan is having an emotional reaction.”
Hannah looked at the shattered box.
Then at my daughter.
Then at Natalie.
“Watch me.”
Sophie hugged me before leaving.
“Daddy?”
“Yes?”
“Are you still marrying her?”
I looked at Natalie.
“No.”
Natalie’s face changed.
Not heartbreak.
Rage.
“This is ridiculous.”
“No. Locking my child in a room was enough.”
“You’re canceling a wedding over discipline?”
“I’m canceling it because you hurt my daughter.”
She laughed bitterly.
“And the photograph?”
May you like
“That’s why you’re not leaving yet.”
For the first time, she looked afraid.
Related Stories
