Chapter 5 - Bethany's Marriage Was Not What Nathan Thought
Daniel left Bethany two nights later.
Not permanently.
At least, not yet.
He checked into a hotel and called Nathan from the parking lot.
“I copied the video.”
Nathan stood from the couch.
“Before she took your phone?”
“After.”
“How?”
“Cloud backup.”
Nathan looked toward the hallway.
Rosie was asleep.
“Send it to Allison.”
“I already did.”
Nathan wanted to ask what was on it.
Instead he waited.
Allison called twenty minutes later.
“The video is useful.”
“Useful how?”
“It shows Rosie’s injuries when you carry her into the dining room. It shows Bethany’s statement. It shows you striking her. It shows your mother grabbing you. It shows your father throwing the glass.”
Nathan's chest tightened.
“Anything before I entered?”
“About twenty-three minutes.”
Nathan sat down.
The phone had been recording before the bathroom door opened.
Not everything was clear.
The phone sat across the dining room.
People moved in front of it.
Music played.
Children shouted.
But several conversations were audible.
Marjorie directing Daniel to keep the camera running.
Frank complaining that Nathan was late.
Bethany asking where Rosie had gone.
Then one exchange.
Marjorie said, “Find her. We need that little statement before Nathan gets here.”
Bethany answered, “She keeps saying she doesn't want to.”
Marjorie replied, “Then make it fun.”
Nathan closed his eyes.
“Anything else?”
“Yes.”
Ten minutes later, Bethany returned to the dining room alone.
Daniel asked where Rosie was.
Bethany said, “Bathroom. She’s having one of her dramatic episodes.”
Then Marjorie said something quieter.
The microphone barely caught it.
“Leave her. Nathan will be here soon.”
Nathan stared at the wall.
His mother had known Rosie was crying in the bathroom.
Maybe not about the injuries.
But she knew Rosie was distressed.
And she left her there because Nathan was coming.
Allison continued.
“The most important part may be after you leave.”
Nathan almost did not want to hear it.
“What happens?”
“Your mother picks up the phone.”
“And?”
“She asks Daniel whether the punch is visible.”
Nathan felt something inside him drop.
“What does Daniel say?”
“He says yes.”
“And then?”
“Your mother says, ‘Good. At least something useful came out of this disaster.’”
Nathan said nothing for several seconds.
His own mistake had become her opportunity in real time.
Allison reminded him again.
“This doesn't erase the punch.”
“I know.”
“It does provide context.”
“I know.”
After the call, Daniel came over.
Nathan opened the door but did not invite him in immediately.
“Why did you stay married to her?”
Daniel knew who he meant.
“Bethany?”
“Yes.”
Daniel looked down.
“Because she wasn't like this at first.”
“What changed?”
Daniel laughed without humor.
“A lot.”
He eventually came inside.
Over coffee, Daniel told Nathan something the family had never discussed openly.
Bethany had spent almost a year helping Marjorie care for Rosie after Lauren died.
Not because Nathan had asked her to.
Because Marjorie constantly asked.
Pickup.
Dinner.
Bath.
Party planning.
Weekend errands.
Bethany had begun resenting both Rosie and Nathan.
“I told her to stop helping,” Daniel said.
“Why didn't she?”
“Your mom made her feel guilty.”
Nathan looked at him.
“That's not an excuse.”
“No.”
Daniel nodded.
“But it's part of why she was angry at a four-year-old for not doing what Mom wanted.”
Nathan finally saw one layer beneath Bethany's cruelty.
Not a monster appearing from nowhere.
A resentful adult who had allowed pressure, jealousy, and anger to collect until she directed it at the smallest person in the room.
May you like
Understanding did not make Nathan forgive her.
It made him more certain Rosie needed distance from all of them.
Related Stories
