Chapter 2 - THE GIRL MY WIFE NEVER MENTIONED
Emma was admitted to UPMC Bedford for observation.
Her temperature returned to normal after warm fluids and blankets. A pediatrician documented bruising around one ankle and scratches across her back. None were life-threatening, but every mark had to be photographed because of where she had been found.
Child Protective Services sent an investigator before sunrise.
I gave her my deployment records, the emails Brenda had sent about Emma, and the messages showing I had believed our daughter was safe at home.
Brenda arrived at eight.
She stopped in the hospital doorway when she saw the mud still dried beneath Emma’s fingernails.
“Oh my God.”
Emma turned toward me and tightened her arms around my neck.
Brenda’s face folded.
“What did Mom do?”
“You told me she was watching Emma.”
“I thought she was.”
“She put our daughter in a hole.”
Brenda covered her mouth.
Her reaction looked like shock until I mentioned the name on the metal tag.
“Who is Sarah Chun?”
Brenda lowered her hand.
She sat without asking.
“Where did you hear that name?”
“It was in the second hole.”
For several seconds, she stared at the floor.
Then she said, “Sarah was a foster child.”
“Your mother fostered children?”
“Only for a few years.”
“You never told me.”
“I don’t talk about that house.”
We had been married for twelve years. I knew Myrtle had raised Brenda alone after her husband left. I knew Brenda moved out at eighteen and avoided overnight visits.
I did not know another child had lived there.
Sarah Chun had been nine years old when she entered Myrtle’s home in 1999. According to Brenda, she was quiet, small for her age, and frightened of closed rooms.
“She stayed about six months,” Brenda said.
“What happened to her?”
“Mom said the county moved her.”
“Did you see her leave?”
Brenda’s eyes filled.
“I was fourteen.”
“That isn’t an answer.”
“No.”
The state police called while we were speaking. The second pit contained human remains, but identification would require forensic work. The metal tag appeared to be from a child’s backpack.
The property became a crime scene.
Myrtle was taken to the barracks for questioning but was not immediately arrested. A body hidden for decades required more than suspicion and a name on a tag.
Brenda walked into the hallway.
I followed.
“What do you know?”
“I know Mom punished us by making us stand outside,” she said. “Sometimes in the storm cellar. Sometimes in holes she dug for fence posts.”
“Us?”
“Me and Sarah.”
The plural changed the room.
Brenda said Myrtle belonged to a small religious group that believed public shame and physical discomfort could drive disobedience from children. The group dissolved years earlier after its leader was sued for abusing teenagers.
Myrtle kept the methods.
“Did she ever put you in that second hole?”
“No.”
“Did you see Sarah there?”
Brenda pressed her palms against the wall.
“One night Sarah ran to my room. She said Mom had hurt her. I told her to stop making things worse.”
Her voice broke.
“The next morning Sarah was gone.”
I wanted to ask why Brenda had left Emma with the woman she was describing.
The answer was lying in the hospital bed behind us.
She had known enough to fear Myrtle.
Yet she sent our child there anyway.
CPS issued an emergency safety plan. Emma would remain with me after discharge. Brenda could see her only under supervision until investigators understood why she had left a toddler in Myrtle’s care.
Brenda did not fight the restriction.
That frightened me more than anger would have.
She sat beside Emma’s bed and whispered, “I’m sorry.”
Emma watched her without reaching back.
Later, Trooper Cross brought me the list of items recovered near the remains: pieces of fabric, a rusted zipper, two plastic buttons, and a small silver charm shaped like a moon.
Brenda saw the photograph.
She began shaking.
“That was mine,” she said.
“The charm?”
“I gave it to Sarah the night she disappeared.”
May you like
The second hole did not contain only evidence connected to Sarah.
It contained proof that Brenda had been close enough to know more than she had told anyone.
