Chapter 12 - What Richard Believed He Had Earned
Richard agreed to a settlement conference regarding the house, separate from the criminal investigation into the punch and suspected documents.
Alex, Helen, Richard, and their attorneys sat around a rectangular table in downtown Columbus.
Richard looked exhausted.
His construction company had stopped taking new jobs.
“I put six years into Samuel,” he said.
Alex answered, “I know.”
The lack of argument unsettled him.
“I cleaned that man after accidents. I drove him to cardiology. I climbed onto that roof in January.”
“I know.”
“And you called every Sunday from Seattle.”
“Yes.”
Richard laughed bitterly.
“You get the house.”
“I didn’t write the deed.”
“You accepted it.”
“Yes.”
That answer mattered too.
Alex could not pretend he was merely dragged into this.
He had accepted ownership years earlier because Samuel asked.
He had never questioned what it meant for Helen.
Richard turned toward her.
“You knew.”
“Yes.”
“You watched me believe that place would be ours.”
“Yes.”
“Why?”
Helen’s voice broke.
“Because telling you the truth would have meant admitting I was afraid of you.”
Richard’s face changed.
No lawyer interrupted.
Helen continued.
“When your business failed, you scared me. Not because you hit me. You didn’t. Because every conversation became about what I had to sacrifice so you wouldn’t fail.”
Richard looked away.
“I was trying to save our life.”
“You were trying to save the version of yourself who never failed.”
Alex heard the echo of his own life in it.
Career.
Distance.
Control.
Different scale.
Same temptation.
Richard finally looked at Alex.
“I didn’t forge Samuel’s signature.”
“Then explain the deed.”
“My office manager prepared it from something your mother told me Samuel wanted.”
“Did Samuel sign it?”
Richard hesitated.
“I thought he had.”
Rachel asked, “Did you instruct Paula Reed to notarize it?”
“No.”
“Did you submit it to a lender knowing it had never been recorded?”
“Yes.”
“Why?”
“Because Helen told me the house was supposed to be hers.”
Helen closed her eyes.
There was the emotional truth under the legal one.
Richard believed entitlement and legality would eventually catch up with each other.
When they did not, he tried to force them together.
Alex asked:
“Why punch me?”
Richard’s answer came immediately.
“Because I saw that envelope and knew Samuel had beaten me again.”
Not Alex.
Samuel.
Richard had spent years competing with a dead man’s judgment.
The house was property.
May you like
It was also the final vote in an argument about whether Richard had ever truly belonged in the family.
Understanding that did not make Alex willing to give it to him.
